​Gracious Garlic Shrimp

 Shrimp in our homemade garlic sauce served over rice or linguini     22.99


Linguini and Clams

 Little neck Clams served in either a red or white sauce   19.99


Matey's Mussels

 Mussels Marinara served over linguini (sweet, medium or hot)   18.99


Shrimp Primavera

 Delicately prepared with broccoli, carrots and onions in a creamy sauce    24.99


Crab Meat Italia

 Crab Meat sauteed with Italian spices tossed with linguini    26.99


Penne ala Vodka with Scallops

 Scallops sauteed in a pink vodka sauce tossed with penne pasta    ​25.99


Shrimp Parmigiana

 Shrimp fried and baked with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese    ​24.99


Chicken Parmigiana

 Chicken Breast fried and baked with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese    ​16.99


Tottenville Shrimp

 Fried Jumbo Shrimp served over a portion of pasta (your choice) in our homemade marinara sauce    ​22.99


​       Salmon Specialties


Captain's Salmon

 Broiled farm raised boneless fillet     21.99


Salmon Michael Angelo

 Baked with thin slices of potato, onion and special spices    23.99


Salmon Corina

 Served with hot cherry peppers, broccoli, carrots, onions and mushrooms    23.99


Salmon Dijionnaise

 Baked with a special dijionnaise sauce   22.99


Herb-Crusted Salmon

 Fillet encrusted with herbs, pan seared and baked to perfection    22.99


Blackened Salmon

 Fillet encrusted with Cajun seasoning and blackened    22.99


Crabmeat Stuffed Salmon

 Boneless fillet stuffed with our Crab Meat stuffing    ​25.99




​        Pasta Specialties    


Pasta dinners served with a cup of Manhattan Chowder or Salad, Dinner Rolls and Butter.


Plate Share Charge - $2.00

Some prices may change without notice due to availability.

*Green Denotes Land Lubbers Items*


​All dinners served with a cup of Manhattan Chowder or Salad, Freedom Fries or Rice (mashed or baked potato after 3pm) Coleslaw, Applesauce or Vegetable, Dinner Rolls and Butter.


Fresh Seafood

Gregory's Seafood Market & Restaurant